Book: Do You Dream of Terra-Two by Temi Oh
Ugh, so behind with these. I have some time off work so I am going to try and blast through my backlog as I have started my Hugo reading now and I definitely want to cover that.
I have had the pleasure of meeting Temi twice and she is honestly a genuinely lovely person. Listening to her talk definitely made me want to read this, combined with listening to Emma Newman froth about it (they were at the same event together). As usual, I can’t do hardbacks due to stupid joints and their constant malfunctioning (they are too heavy basically and cause pain if I read them for any length of time) so thus settled into wait for the paperback.
The book follows the story of six teenagers who are chosen to on a long mission to a planet that has been designated Terra-Two. Their journey is expected to take them 20-30 years so they will arrive when they are in their late 30s to early 40s. They are the back-up crew to the adults, expected to learn their jobs so they can take over when needed later on in the journey.
I will admit that I had assumed that the book was going to be covering the whole journey and dealing with the interpersonal problems that would arise from such a group of people being stuck with each other in such a small space for a long period of time, but that isn’t entirely how it goes. This isn’t meant as a spoiler, just as a warning, only a relatively short time of the journey is covered in the book.
There was a lot I liked about the way the relationships played out between the characters, there were some pretty dark moments as well, no sexual violence just the regular sort in case you are worried, but potential trigger for bullying type situations so be aware of that.
One thing that did bother me in regards to the character relationships and their development though. Early on there is a character who does not want to have sex, but the way it is framed she seems to think the whole thing is horrible and not something that she wants, which is a pretty clear indicator of a certain type of asexuality. Then later on she seems utterly happy to have sex with someone else, with no explanation of her very major change of views on the matter. As an asexual person who is often desperate for more representation, this was really quite frustrating.
The only other slight quibble I had may actually be more of a marketing thing than anything else. So I love Planetfall, I liked the weird mystical seeming stuff that permeating parts of that book. As a book where the premise was about a colony on an alien world that had been established after they followed a prophet to the place, that seemed to entirely match my expectations of what I was going to read. There is a similar element in this book where there are some weird dreams about the place they are going to, but in a book that was marketed without that expectation it felt a little jarring to me. Like I said though, not sure that is something I can particularly blame the author for but it is something to be aware of.
But overall I really liked the book and it’s a pretty good debut. The ending does feel a little abrupt and the way it ends may annoy some people, but it did make a certain amount of sense to me, even if a part of me can’t help but want to know how the story of the characters ends, even if that isn’t the story the book is telling me.